About Dr. Melissa Steiner

This author has not yet filled in any details.
So far Dr. Melissa Steiner has created 12 blog entries.

Balak 5778 – Blessings, Blocks and Hidden Things

Before I dive into the story of Balak and share some reflections, I feel the need to provide full disclosure about this parsha. Balak has become a Steiner family tradition. Ron read Balak at his Bar Mitzvah in Israel and so did his brother, David. Rachel read Balak at her Bat Mitzvah in Israel and so did Lilly. So, I have some familial material to draw upon and you’ll hear some of their lessons in this dvar.

In parshat Balak, we read that Balak, King of Moab, fears that he cannot defeat the Israelites. So instead, Balak hires the prophet Balaam to curse the Jews. God spoke to Balaam to explain that, basically, this assignment is a waste of time.

God said to Balaam, “You shall not go with them! You shall not curse the people because they are blessed.”

Balak and the elders of Moab would not take no for an answer and so, Balaam and his donkey set out on the journey.  God sends a sword-carrying angel to block his path. The donkey sees the angel and she turns away from the road and into a field. In response, Balaam beats the donkey to return to the road. The angel blocks the way. Two more times the donkey tries to move forward and stops abruptly when the angel blocks the path; Balaam beats the donkey each time. After the third beating, the donkey speaks! She asks Balaam “what have I done that you beat me three times?” Balaam says to the donkey that she has humiliated him. Only then does God open Balaam’s eyes and he sees the angel blocking the path. He falls to his knees and states that he will not continue the journey to curse the Jews. God tells Balaam he should continue; but, he must speak whatever words God puts into his mouth. And we know that when Balaam opened his mouth to curse the Jews, only blessings came forth. And now several thousands of years later, every morning service begins with:

“Mah tovu ohalecha Yaakov, mishk’notecha Yisrael”

“How good are your tents, O Jacob, your dwellings, O Israel!”

Cantor Ellen Dreskin writes in the book “Text Messages” that ‘… these simple words emphasize the blessing of each individual’s role in our community, the blessing that is contained in every aspect of our own personalities, and our obligation to attempt to speak blessings and be blessings at every moment of our lives.”

In her Bat Mitzvah speech, Lilly didn’t focus on the blessings part so much. Lilly gave the following two lessons:

  • “If you see wrong-doing you should try to stop it. Sometimes you speak up in defense and other times, you speak up for the purpose of educating the person who is doing wrong. For example, even when I was little, I realized the importance of speaking up when I told my teacher, Ms. Starry, that one of my classmates wasn’t sharing his toy truck. It is important that I spoke up because his lack of sharing was hurting someone else.”
  • “Another lesson is that your friends and family look out for you and steer you away from bad decisions. For example, in preparation for high school, Rachel and her friend, Christine, warned me which hallways I should avoid when passing between classes so that I would get to class on time and so that I would stay out of trouble.”

That God gave the donkey the ability to see the angel and further to speak out loud is akin to recognizing a wrong-doing and speaking out against it. It is our duty to speak for ourselves, our family, friends and community whenever there is something wrong in how we are being treated or how we are treating each other. You might think of the donkey in today’s terms as an ‘upstander’; we need people like that – who look out for each other and who stand-up against injustices.

It is wrong to blindly follow our own desires or attend only to our own needs. Balaam said that the donkey humiliated him – he was concerned with how the donkey’s lack of obedience reflected on himself! Instead, we (and Balaam) need to look outside ourselves and take care of each other.

It is especially relevant in today’s climate – we need to move beyond our own personal needs, our own personal comforts and privileges. Can you empathize with those who are escaping persecution in their own lands and seek refuge at our borders? Can you offer time or money or food to those who live without adequate means to care for themselves and their families? Can you empathize with those who feel targeted, threatened, or insecure about police officer behaviors?

Can you recognize that you are an example of privilege? I can… and it was a handful of years ago when I first really saw that privilege in action… Fourth of July at our house with the Sullums and we decided to shoot some fireworks in the baseball field across from our house. We weren’t the only people setting off fireworks in that field. That’s within city limits. It’s against the law to use fireworks within city limits. And when the police came by… they barely spoke to us… they barely spoke to the white folks. There was a more lengthy conversation with our Hispanic neighbors.

We should take that ‘privilege’ and use it to help others.

At Lilly’s Bat Mitzvah, Ron added his spin on Balak. Ron’s lesson is to look at the shape Hebrew text of this parsha. Amazingly it is a single block of text – there are no “paragraph’ or chapter breaks.

Ron thinks this represents our family unit – that we stick together. It symbolizes the strength of our family. Perhaps it is representative of the Jewish community, standing together as a whole?

Maybe speaking blessings, acting as a blessing, caring for others and speaking out against injustices… these behaviors are the building blocks of our community.

And what of these hidden things that I mentioned in the title?

Some hidden things are things we need to be protected from:

  • The angel was hidden from Balaam and the donkey tried to protect him.
  • Parents protect their children from all kinds of “hidden” dangers – parents use their experience to guide their kids toward being safe and toward making good decisions.
  • Natural gas – you can’t see the vapors and unless the gas company adds a pungent odor we wouldn’t be able to smell that gas either. So, the gas company protects us.
  • All kinds of illnesses fall into this category as well.
    • Cancer, MS, Diabetes, fibromyalgia: just a few examples of illnesses that you can’t see from the outside and if remain unknown to the patient… well, that’s kind of obvious what happens to the patient. But when your family or your community is unaware of your physical pain or limitations, they may push you toward joining in on activities that don’t match your current abilities, or they may inadvertently say something hurtful.
    • Mental illness, including depression: if not identified and acknowledged can lead to misunderstanding of the source of a person’s behavior and to incorrectly placing blame and that can further lead to ostracizing or isolation of that person.

And then there are those things which are hidden, and probably should remain hidden…  because they are personal. In a dvar torah from 2002, Rabbi Dovid Green wrote:

“In counter distinction to modern western culture where all dirty laundry is washed in public, the Torah attitude is that not everything is for the public eye. Some things are meant to remain known only within the community, or the family, or between husband and wife. When everything intimate is public knowledge, it violates the goodness of the tents of Yaakov.”
https://torah.org/torah-portion/dvartorah-5760-balak/

I’ll leave you with one more thought… sometimes there are things within each of us which are themselves hidden but which define us, and shape our lives, and guide our behavior:

  • Commitment
  • Caring and Kindness
  • Love
  • Patience

In the documentary about Fred Rogers (currently available in theaters), you’ll hear a quote along these lines. I think I found the original source from the book “The Little Prince”:

“It is only with the heart that one can see rightly; what is essential is invisible to the eye.”

Shabbat Shalom

Parshat Korach – 5776 – Rebellion: Lessons for the rebel and for the leader

Basic Story: Korach, one of the rich leaders of the Levites, and a cousin of Moses and Aaron, felt that he had been slighted and overlooked in the distribution of the highest priestly honors and leadership. Realizing that despite his riches and influence he alone could do very little to shake the people’s faith and confidence in Moses and Aaron, Korach looked for associates in his campaign against them.

Korach found Dathan and Abiram, who had been trouble-makers in Egypt and the ringleaders of disaffection and rebellion. They were the first to rally to the party of Korach, and they were his most eager agents among their tribesmen. With their experienced and clever campaigning along with Korach’s money and influence, they grew the rebellion to about 250 people; they now felt bold enough to go out into the open and speak up against Moses’ leadership of the people. Adopting the mantle of piety and justice and arrogance, and pretending to be a champion of his people, Korach accused Moses and Aaron of imposing their leadership upon the community. “You take too much upon yourselves, for the entire congregation are all holy, and the Lord is in their midst. So why do raise yourselves above the Lord’s assembly?” said Korach (Numbers 16:3)

Moses’ response: Moses spoke to Korach and his party, and told them to prepare themselves for the next day, when G‑d would show whom He considered worthy to serve Him as priests. Then Moses spoke to Korach privately and warned him against his lust for personal honor. “Is it not enough that the G‑d of Israel has distinguished you from the congregation of Israel to draw you near to Him, to perform the service in the Tabernacle of the L-rd and to stand before the congregation to minister to them? ” Moses said (Numbers 16:9). But his words fell on deaf ears.

End Result: The next day, standing in defiance, Korach and his followers were swallowed up by the earth and perished.

So, what are we supposed to learn from this story? How does it relate to our lives?

Initially, the idea for this dvar focused on my favorite topic of parenting lessons from the Torah. Right now that feels like super, low-hanging fruit to talk about how a 2-year old rebels at being told “No” or for being shushed. And the lessons that parents need to learn about having patience and to understand the tantrum from the child’s point of view. Maybe the kid is simply tired, or hungry. We moved to Texas right before Rachel turned 3 years old and we totally turned her world upside down – we changed her house, her daily caregiver, her routine – and she repaid us with a nightly tantrum… until we realized that she needed an opportunity to control something – anything – in her world. So, each night we let her decide which placemats to use at the table and where we should each sit. By seeing it from her perspective, we were able to return some control to Rachel and she stopped rebelling.

But you know… I HAVE to move on from these parenting of little kid lessons and see the ADULT meaning of Torah in our lives. So, in preparing this dvar with a different focus, what are the lessons from Korach that we should be taking home today?

The first question I asked is why does Korach rebel against authority (the priestly class)? I’m pretty sure that Korach is feeling jealous – HE wants to be a leader in the community. Additionally, Korach disbelieves that the priestly class was selected by God and was instead a man-made; and if the community leadership is man-made, why can’t it be with Korach at the helm?

Korach wants to make his case but needs supporters and when he finds them, he works hard to ensure they have the same distrust of the leaders. He turns his supporters against the leaders and he does it with vehemence.
That sounds quite a lot like what is happening in our world today, doesn’t it?

  • Political campaigns that are focused smearing the opposition and name-calling
  • People using social media to bolster support for their points of view

While neither of those examples are motivated by jealousy, the mechanism of finding support for their points of view results in loud and boisterous gatherings of people. In some cases, people are taking to the streets to make sure they are heard; and in some cases, people are just joining in political solidarity for a common cause. But in all honestly, those large crowds have become really scary to me.

Yes, I value the ability to speak openly in this country.

Yes, I value the ability to gather freely for a common cause.

But these gatherings for the purpose of being heard feel like stepping into the target zone. And that’s kind of what happened on Thursday night in Dallas – a free speech gathering of citizens to show support against unjust police brutality in America became a horrific scene of terrified people running out of that target zone. No, the everyday citizen was not the specific target Thursday night… but choosing to gather openly in support of a hot topic is too risky for me. I fear the mob mentality.

Call me chicken… or uncommitted that I am not strong enough in my beliefs to march in protest. I don’t really care how you choose to categorize me. I am scared to be so open.

And that really pains me.

I’m don’t consider myself a bystander – I will stand up for what I believe and I will step in to help. But I feel I have to be very choosy. And rational – not emotional. Maybe it’s because I am not in my twenties and I have children and I feel responsible and most protective toward them. In fact, I have been known to be quite the Mama Bear to defend my children against verbal attacks… I cannot even imagine how I would respond to a physical one.

 

Lessons to be learned

Jealousy is a destructive behavior. It motivates people to behave in their own interest at the expense of others. A jealous man quite often ends up hurting himself (and those around him).

Desperation is dangerous. A desperate man is motivated to act emotionally and that short-term thinking usually ends up with a poor result.

Be careful who you choose as your leader. You need to make sure to use your head and not your emotions when choosing to follow someone’s lead. Think for yourself, but not only about yourself. You must think about how supporting a particular leader is good for your family, your community, your country.

Don’t let yourself be talked into something you don’t believe, or that you know is wrong.

Do speak up for what you believe… but don’t try to sway others to your same beliefs with only emotion. Use rational arguments that you can support – not hyperbole, tears, horrific images, threats, name-calling, or sensationalism.

Don’t feel helpless or desperate. You are not alone. You are not helpless. There are others around you who feel the same way or who at least understand and accept your feelings and beliefs. It is okay and beneficial to seek them out and find your support. Quiet support. Calm support.

Shabbat Shalom

Go to Top